Emma Jones
Yellowstone American Single Malt Review
Yellowstone American Single Malt whiskey is the new permanent expression from Limestone Branch Distillery Co., joining other permanent Yellowstone expressions. Distilled and aged in Indiana, this whiskey is part of the rapidly expanding American single malt category, which is not officially defined at the moment.
Nose
The first waft yields an undulating heat, while the aroma evolves to reveal layers of fruit scents, starting with a soft, sweet pear and a more vibrant note of ripe apricots. A perfume of stone fruits delicately entwines with these primary scents, deepening the complexity of the aroma. Underneath it all, there’s a faint whisper of floral notes, an almost ethereal, somewhat grassy undertone that slightly tempers the fruity richness. Finally, the scent of breakfast cereal makes its mark, grounding the aroma with a homey, comforting familiarity.
Palate
Heat from the aroma subsides, giving way to an immediate swell of pear, mingling with the bolder essence of stone fruits. It’s further sweetened by threads of velvety caramel, which weaves through the sip. The whiskey boasts a medium body that fills the palate with a certain richness, though it doesn’t overwhelm it and results in an enjoyable sip.
Finish
Heat returns at the forefront of the finish, brought forward with a sweet undertone. Soon after, an undertow of flavors sweeps in, leading with graham cracker, followed closely by freshly baked pie crust. As it progresses, it transitions to a long, dry retreat.
Uniqueness
Unlike bourbon, the American single malt category is not legally defined, so right now you need to do a little research to know if your bottle would qualify based on the proposed definition. But in most cases, what we’re seeing typically conforms to the proposed rules. Yellowstone forgoes the extremes, instead finding a place in average/enjoyable/approachable territory. It’s a product that could draw people in first simply by the gravity of the Yellowstone brand and its well-done label.
Value
Yellowstone American Single Malt plays an interesting role in the market. It offers a good flavor profile, but doesn’t scream single malt and doesn’t try to be anything more than it is. It’s $55, which is a lot, but for this new(ish) category and newly introduced whiskey, it’s not that unusual. I probably won’t rush to buy another bottle, but if someone asked for a recommendation for an American single malt whiskey to try, it’s $55 well spent.
Overall
We’re at the forefront of the American single malt category. Bourbon drinkers who are just getting started should take a step back. Yellowstone American Single Malt helps set the pace for what it means to be an American single malt with mainstream appeal. It doesn’t taste very malty, but it follows a flavor profile more rooted in bourbon. It is fairly fruit-forward, and this combination may appeal to typical bourbon drinkers more than many American single malts on the market. It is fairly average overall, however the category has yet to really define the boundaries of its quality range. Average isn’t just enough, it’s actually probably ideal in this case, as it comes with undeniable approachability
Classification: American Single Malt
Company: Limestone Branch Distillery Co.
Distillery: Sourced from an undisclosed distillery(ies) in Indiana
Release Date: March 2023 (Ongoing)
Proof: 108
Age: NAS (Aged 4 years according to the company)
Mashbill: 100% Malted Barley
Color: Rose Gold
MSRP: $55 (2023)
A smooth and balanced drinking experience. The flavors of ripe apricots and sweet pears continue to shine on the palate, creating a delicious and fruity profile. The addition of caramel adds depth and sweetness, creating a pleasant complexity. The medium body of the whiskey allows the flavors to linger on the palate, inviting you to savor each sip. Overall, the palate of Yellowstone American Single Malt is smooth, flavorful, and satisfying.
Finish
The finish of Yellowstone American Single Malt is long and warming. The flavors of pear and stone fruits gradually fade, leaving a gentle sweetness on the palate. There is a subtle hint of oak and a touch of spice that adds depth to the finish. It is a satisfying and well-balanced ending to the whiskey, leaving you with a lingering warmth and a desire for another sip.
Overall, the new permanent expression of Yellowstone American Single Malt showcases the distillery’s commitment to producing high-quality whiskey. It offers a complex and flavorful experience, with layers of fruit, gentle sweetness, and a touch of spice. Whether enjoyed neat or in a cocktail, this whiskey is sure to please whiskey enthusiasts and newcomers alike.
A pleasantly balanced drinking experience. The floral notes from the nose make a subtle appearance on the palate, adding a touch of elegance and complexity. The finish is smooth and lingers with a gentle warmth, leaving behind a lingering sweetness that invites you to take another sip.
Overall, the Yellowstone American Single Malt is a delightful whiskey that showcases the potential of the American single malt category. It is a well-crafted spirit with layers of flavor and a balanced profile. Whether enjoyed neat or in a cocktail, this whiskey is sure to please whiskey enthusiasts looking for something new and exciting.